Put it on a flat table
Ask for a picture of the edge at table height. Look for raised corners and waves in the middle. Check both faces; a ruler laid across the top is not proof that the whole mat lies flat.
Look at heavily used lines
Ask for a close-up with side lighting where most cuts were made. A deep, permanent groove is different from a light surface mark. If you cut long straight strips, look for an uninterrupted working area without a deep track or split.
Measure the working area
Compare the largest piece you plan to cut with the area you can actually use, not just the mat’s outside dimensions. Check whether the grid uses centimetres or inches. If you cut with your own ruler, compare the scales.
Do not count on flattening it later
OLFA recommends storing its mats flat and away from extreme temperatures, and says a warped OLFA mat cannot be flattened. Check the maker’s instructions for other models. If accuracy depends on a flat surface, buy a mat that already sits flat.